Tennessee Historical Quarterly Struggle Within Struggle without Discussion
I’m trying to learn for my History class and I’m stuck. Can you help?
You will be discussing Aaron Purcell’s “Struggle Within, Struggle Without” from the Tennessee Historical Quarterly. (attached) Your writing should include your reflections on the readings and can engage the content.
As you are thinking about responding to this reading, it may be helpful to think about the following questions, though you should in no way feel limited to discussing these points.Do not use any additional resources.Please answer in essay form not question and answer format. There should be a minimum of 800 words.
-
- THESIS: What is this reading’s thesis? Does it have one major point? Or multiple points?
- IMPORTANCE: WHY does this thesis matter? How does this book complement or challenge the thesis presented in other works that we have read?
- EVIDENCE: What evidence does the author use to support his/her thesis? What types of evidence? How does this evidence connect to the thesis and any sub-points?
- COGENCY AND CRITIQUE: What is MOST convincing about this book’s use of evidence? What is LEAST convincing? Where might it have been improved? How might you have improved it?
- RELEVANCY: Would this thesis have been relevant if the author had been looking elsewhere, at another group of individuals, at another community, at another time period?