Pakistan

Pharmacies are managed by a assortment of dispensers in footings of making, cognition and experience. The survey aimed to measure cognition, experience and making of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan.

Methods

A comparative cross sectional survey was conducted at a indiscriminately selected sample of 371 pharmaceuticss in the three metropoliss of Pakistan. A questionnaire for informations aggregation was developed and finalized by focussed group treatments and pilot testing. The information was coded, entered and analyzed by utilizing SPSS Version 16.

Consequences

Fifty per centum of the respondents had right cognition of room temperature. Merely 11.11 % and 5.9 % of the respondents knew about OTC and POM. While 87.6 % , 88.1 % , 58.7 and 95.7 % did non cognize the significance of h.s, q.d, SOS and p.r.n. The respondents did non cognize right the position of deltacortil, septran and fansidar in 26.7 % , 64.2 % , and 44.5 % of the instances severally. While 50.4 % , 77.4 % and 63.6 % were incognizant about the position of Augmentin, metronidazole and Lomotil.

Decisions

The overall cognition and preparation of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan is unequal. Presence of qualified individual equipped with sufficient cognition and preparation is required.

Key words

Community pharmaceutics, cognition, experience, making, dispensers, Pakistan

Important Definitions

Pharmacy: A pharmaceutics is any mercantile establishments selling allopathic medical specialties entirely, or homeopathic or herbal medical specialties if sold aboard allopathic medical specialties.

Dispensers: A dispenser is any individual who prepares or gives out medical specialty, irrespective of preparation.

Qualified individual: Persons finishing B.Pharm/Pharm.D, sheepskin in pharmaceutics and certified class of drug dispensing or compounders was considered as qualified individuals.

Background

Knowledge and preparation of wellness professionals is critical for supplying appropriate wellness attention. Proper making and preparation of dispensers can help in accomplishing safe usage of medicines for the patients go toing community pharmaceuticss. Identifying the spread in pattern and preparation dispensers at community pharmaceuticss can supply improved, simple, healing attention services to profit the community [ 1 ] . It is indispensable that the forces managing medical specialties must be equipped with proper making, experience and cognition. They must be cognizant of the factors which influence drug quality and stairss to guarantee that the drugs dispensed to patients are safe and effectual [ 2 ] .

Community pharmaceuticss in developing states frequently lack qualified and trained forces to hive away, label and manage drugs in appropriate manner [ 3 ] . It has been reported that in most of the instances dispensers lack formal instruction and preparation and those who are trained are largely non available at these pharmaceuticss [ 4-7 ] . While selling medical specialties it is of import to understand that which medical specialty can be sold with or without prescription. However surveies have reported sale of all types of medical specialties to all patients irrespective of any moral and legal considerations [ 5, 8 ] .

The community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan are known to be managed by a diverseness of dispensers in footings of their making, cognition, experience and ages. Inadequate cognition of the dispensers at community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan has been reported [ 9, 10 ] . The making of dispensers vary from qualified druggist, pharmaceutics helpers, pharmaceutics technicians, sheepskin holders in pharmaceutics, to medical physicians, nurses and to the individuals holding no dispensing related instruction and bulk constitute this group [ 1, 3, 9-11 ] . These dispensers have minimum formal instruction with 10 to 12 old ages of schooling and with small or no professional preparation [ 3, 9-11 ] . Even this nominal instruction of primary or secondary degree is seen as a commercial necessity and non as a legal demand to be followed. They largely rely on information gathered by the representatives of pharmaceutical companies therefore selling medical specialties under the influence of publicity of drugs by the pharmaceutical companies [ 10 ] . With this province of making and preparation, here these dispensers are responsible for maps of a dispenser, shop keeper, stock list director, comptroller, prescriber, information supplier and patient counsellor [ 12 ] . Sing the range of their services it seems that they are really specialised professionals holding ample cognition. In existent universe, nevertheless, there is no existent established standard for minimal cognition of dispensers and really small is known about their background experience, perceptual experiences, instruction, preparation and cognition on how they handle the proficient undertakings of drugs storage, quality care, and pull offing assortment of patients with or without prescriptions [ 10, 12-14 ] .

This insufficiency of scientific cognition among dispensers contributes to the prevailing low quality services at community pharmaceuticss. This will stay as the chief hurdle at community pharmaceuticss unless the spreads in the cognition of dispensers are identified and corrected. The importance of making, experience, preparation and cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss is non much emphasized in the state. The present survey was conducted to document and compare the province of cognition, experience and making of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in three major countries of Pakistan viz. Islamabad ( national capital ) , Peshawar ( capital of Khyberpakhtoonkhwa state ) and Lahore ( capital of Punjab state ) .

Methodology

Keeping in position the federal administrative and regulative construction of the state the capital metropolis Islamabad was selected which is besides geographically in the center of the two states. Peshawar is located towards the North of Islamabad ( 184 Km off with 2 hours drive from federal capital ) while Lahore is located in the South ( 384 km off with 4.5 hours drive from federal capital ) . The survey was conducted at 371 indiscriminately selected pharmaceuticss in three metropoliss viz. Islamabad ( 118 ) , Peshawar ( 120 ) and Lahore ( 133 ) . The survey population included all community pharmacy mercantile establishments in Islamabad, Lahore and Peshawar metropoliss selling allopathic medical specialties. Pharmacies located in infirmary and private dispensaries were excluded and any mercantile establishment meeting this definition comprised the trying unit, dispenser being the sampling component. List of medical shops were obtained from several District Health Offices. The most experient dispenser was selected from the pharmaceutics for interview.

The Data aggregation tool was developed by focussed group treatments and utilizing the mentions of Drug Act of Pakistan 1976 and relevant regulations under, Good Pharmacy Practice guidelines, International Pharmaceutical Federation ( FIP ) guidelines and review book of pharmaceuticss. Focus group treatments were carried out with community druggist, drug inspectors, academe and members of consumer groups for development and finalisation of informations aggregation tool. Face and content cogency was built through panel of pharmaceutics research experts, community druggists, statistician and pilot testing.

Structured questionnaire was used to acquire information on the cognition of the dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss. The value of cronbachaa‚¬a„?s alpha was 0.726 which was applied to measure the dependability and internal consistence of the tool. The questionnaire comprised of a sum of 30 three inquiries which included information on demographics, personal information, position in pharmaceutics, degree of instruction, experience, preparation, beginnings of information, storage temperature, prescription nomenclatures, position of drugs, positions and jobs about profession and suggestions for betterment. The minimal demand for cognition of dispensers was elaborated and transformed into mensurable indexs, which included three subscales: subscale I Knowledge about storage temperature ( 3-6 ) , subscale II Knowledge about prescription nomenclatures ( 7-14 ) and subscale III Knowledge about position of drugs ( 12-24 ) . The composite mark for all sub graduated tables was 22-44 and lower mark referred to better conformity.

Data was collected by trained informations aggregators after seeking permission from relevant drug inspectors. Local chapters of chemist and pharmacist association were contacted and informed sing the survey. The survey was besides approved by the panel of experts at Research & A ; Development wing of Drug Control Organization at Ministry of Health, Government of Pakistan. Informed and verbal consent for engagement was taken from the respondents. Respondents were ensured for the confidentiality of information verbally every bit good as confidentiality under taking signed by the chief research worker was shown.

After the information aggregation, information was cleaned, coded and entered in SPSS 16 version. Statistical analysis was undertaken to compare the cognition of dispensers sing storage temperature, prescription nomenclatures and position of drugs among independent variables like urban/rural, location of pharmaceuticss, metropoliss, position of dispenser in pharmaceutics, experience, degree of instruction and preparation.

Consequences

A sum of 371 dispensers were interviewed of which 31.8 % were working in Islamabad, 32.3 % in Peshawar and 35.8 % were in Lahore. All of the dispensers were male with average age 35 old ages, changing from 17 to 75 old ages. The position of dispenser in pharmaceutics was diverse 55 % proprietors, 35.3 % employees, 2.7 % partner, and 1.6 % were licensee. The professional making of dispensers varied ; 4 % were pharmacist, 7 % were pharmaceutics helper, 6 % were dispenser sheepskin holders and 80.3 % were non-qualified. The experience was ; 4 % less than a twelvemonth, 9.7 % between 1-2 old ages, 12.9 % between 2-5 old ages and staying 73.3 % had an experience greater than 5 old ages. Merely 14 % of the dispensers had formal preparation in drug dispensing.

Fifty per centum of the respondents had right cognition of room temperature. Refrigerators were available with 76.5 % of the pharmaceuticss while 50.7 % of them were besides selling vaccinums. However 66 % did non cognize which medical specialties to be kept in the icebox and cognition of icebox and vaccinum storage temperature. Merely 11.11 % and 5.9 % of the respondents knew about the significance of OTC and POM severally. However 87.6 % , 88.1 % , 58.7 and 95.7 % did non cognize the significance of h.s, q.d, SOS and p.r.n. The respondents were non cognizant of the position of deltacortil, septran, fansidar, Augmentin, metronidazole and Lomotil as prescription merely medical specialty in 26.7 % , 64.2 % , 44.5 % , 50.4 % , 77.4 % and 63.6 % of the instances severally ( Table I ) .

Books were the most often used informations beginning for information by dispensers. In 46.6 % instances dispensers were confer withing Pharmaguide to acquire the desired information followed by British National Formulary 0.3 % , Drug guide 0.3 % and British Pharmacoepia in 0.3 % of the instances.

In add-on to knowledge appraisal of dispensers, survey besides included some inquiries to happen general views/opinions of dispensers to acquire some penetration into the grounds of prevalent patterns. Seventy two per centum of dispensers claimed to hold some cognition of ordinance while 17.3 % claimed that they are non practised. Twenty seven per centum of dispensers were of the position that ordinance for pharmaceuticss is rough while 46 % believe that they are acceptable. The sale of prescription merely medicines without prescription was considered as a job by 80 % of the dispensers.

Over 90 % of dispensers thought that selling medical specialty is a good occupation and 73.6 % would besides urge this to their households while 80 % were satisfied with their current occupation as dispensers. Bing an honorable and respectable occupation ( 53.6 % ) with ample net incomes ( 26.4 % ) and an chance to be updated with current cognition ( 9.1 % ) were the grounds for fall ining this profession. Dispensers were of the position that they are capable of run intoing the demands of the profession to the full ( 73.6 % ) , to some extent ( 21.8 % ) while 4.6 % believed that they are non run intoing the demands at all. Some of the jobs faced by the dispensers in the profession were patient demand of medical specialties without prescription ( 11.4 % ) , return of expired drugs to the pharmaceutical companies ( 11.4 % ) , clip devouring profession due to long on the job hours ( 10 % ) , ordinance ( 7.9 % ) , and handiness of many trade names in market ( 7.6 % ) , less net income border ( 4.7 % ) , drug supply issues ( 3.8 % ) and illegible prescriptions ( 1.6 % ) .

Over 90 % of dispensers believed that distributing in their pharmaceutics was appropriate. The grounds claimed were no ailments from patients ( 12.1 % ) , ample experience ( 7.1 % ) , following ordinances ( 26.6 % ) , holding intensifying services ( 0.5 % ) , transporting out patient guidance ( 11.5 % ) , selling full scope of medical specialties in good vicinity ( 5.8 % ) and presence of qualified individual ( 3 % ) . But still over 80 % of dispensers felt that they are far behind when compared to international criterions of distributing patterns. The dispensers notify that they can lend to the profession through following ordinances ( 25.3 % ) , by advancing generics ( 3.8 % ) , by take downing the monetary values ( 4 % ) , bettering drug handiness ( 1.6 % ) , by undertaking with unethical selling ( 5.7 % ) and this could be achieved by bettering the regulators attitude ( 4.3 % ) . Ninety per centum dispensers identified the demand for developing with 85 % with the consent of go toing if chance provided.

The median obtained for the cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in the three metropoliss was 33 ( 31-37 ) which when compared with mention graduated table ( 22-44 ) showed unequal cognition. While the average obtained in single metropoliss was 32 ( 29-35 ) in Islamabad, 34 ( 32-36 ) in Peshawar and 35 ( 31-38 ) in Lahore. The cognition of dispensers working in community pharmaceuticss in Islamabad was relatively better than in Peshawar and Lahore.

Kruskal-Wallis trial was used to compare the cognition of dispensers holding different degree of instruction, working experience in three different metropoliss sing storage temperature, prescription nomenclatures and position of drugs. A important difference in the cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in the three metropoliss was observed. Knowledge of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in Islamabad was relatively better than dispensers working in Peshawar and Lahore ( Table II ) . The dispensers holding experience less than one twelvemonth had better cognition in Lahore ( Table III ) . Pharmacists were holding better cognition sing storage temperature, prescription nomenclatures and position of drugs as compared to pharmaceutics helpers, sheepskin holders and salesmen ( Table IV ) .

Mann Whitney and kruskal-wallis trial were used to compare impact of preparation, position in pharmaceutics and rural/urban scene on the cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in the three metropoliss. No important difference was observed among the cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss with different position ( licence, proprietor, partner and employee ) , rural/urban scene and preparation in the three metropoliss.

Discussion

Main findings of the survey

The overall making, cognition and preparation of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan is unequal. The presence of lawfully qualified individual is negligible at the pharmaceuticss and in most of the instances proprietors are replacing the qualified individual [ 8-10, 15, 16 ] . They besides lack any formal dispensing related instruction and preparation [ 17 ] . The present survey highlighted that merely few dispensers received any formal preparation in the past old ages but this preparation could non interpret into their better cognition [ 9 ] .This raises inquiries on the quality of developing received by dispensers in the state. Drug information beginnings used by dispensers extremely influence the quality of their cognition. Most of the dispensers were utilizing Pharma Guide a commercially available collection of medical specialties [ 18, 19 ] . The survey consequences besides highlighted pharmaceutical companies as drug information supplier through medical representatives and drug literature [ 5, 10, 20 ] . The consequences of the survey showed that dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in Islamabad had better cognition as comparison to other two metropoliss. Pharmacists were holding relatively better cognition though their presence at community pharmaceuticss was low. The dispensers holding experience of less than one twelvemonth were holding better cognition in Lahore. This might be linked to more figure of druggist and fresh alumnuss with updated cognition working at community pharmaceuticss in Lahore. The survey highlighted lacks in basic cognition of dispensers sing prescription nomenclatures. The consequences of the survey showed that most of the dispensers were cognizant of the position of Xanax ( lexotanil ) as POM but surprisingly Mentronidazole ( Flagyl ) , Cotrimoxazole ( Septran ) and Coamixiclave ( Augmentin ) which are POM were considered as OTC by dispensers. This lacking cognition can be linked with deficiency of making and preparation. Majority of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss claimed that selling POM medical specialties without prescription is a job. Dispensers believed that they are far behind in their patterns as compared to international criterions though they are carry throughing the local professional demands. With this hapless province of cognition bulk of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss believed that they are capable of run intoing the demands of their profession. It is interesting to detect that dispensers believe that by holding no ailments, ample experience, following ordinances and maintaining full scope of medical specialties they are carry throughing the demand of the profession. This highlights confusion and deficiency of consciousness sing professional duties among dispensers. Majority of them expressed willingness to larn and take part if any chance of preparation is provided. Even though dispensers donaa‚¬a„?t possess proper tools to map, in footings of making and cognition but still they are satisfied with their occupation and would besides urge this to others as they feel it as a profitable white neckband concern with no important jobs. This fact can besides be linked with the current on traveling unbridled scenario in the state in which they can acquire off practising as professionals ; with no making, unequal cognition and appropriate experience, with least demand from regulators and society [ 21 ] .

What is already known on this subject

Inadequate cognition of the dispensers at community pharmaceuticss in Pakistan has been reported [ 9, 10 ] . The importance of making, experience, preparation and cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss is non much emphasized in the state. Very small is known about the background, experience, instruction, preparation and cognition on how they handle the proficient undertakings of drugs storage, quality care, and pull offing assortment of patients with or without prescriptions. The present survey has documented the impact of making, preparation and experience on cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in the state. The survey has besides highlighted jobs faced in this profession and suggestions for bettering the current patterns which has non been antecedently highlighted by any other survey.

What this survey adds

This survey aimed to place and compare the bing spreads in the cognition, making and preparation of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in three major metropoliss of Pakistan. The present survey is important and contributes in this facet as it has assessed and compared the cognition of dispensers holding different makings, working experience, position in pharmaceutics, urban/rural scene and preparation received working in different metropoliss. The survey besides highlighted assorted jobs in the profession and suggestions for the bettering the current state of affairs. This survey will function as a baseline to plan future intercessions to better the cognition of dispensers sing drug usage in order to use maximal potencies of community pharmaceuticss in proviso of better patient oriented services.

Restriction of the survey

Some of the restrictions faced during the survey were fiscal and logistic restraints and political convulsion in the state. Reluctance from dispensers to portion information, existent replies may be different due to the sensitiveness of the inquiries. The cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss was assessed in three major metropoliss and may non be generalizable to the cognition of dispensers working at community pharmaceuticss in other metropoliss of the state.

In decision, deficiency of proper making, preparation and cognition of dispensers is a great challenge for accomplishing effectual wellness of general public go toing community pharmaceuticss. Ambiguity in jurisprudence and its execution and complacency in attitude of relevant interest holders are responsible for such prevalent fortunes. There is a strong demand to implement ordinances to guarantee presence of qualified individual equipped with sufficient cognition and preparation at pharmaceuticss with uninterrupted monitoring plans.

Authoraa‚¬a„?s parts

A.H. had complete entree to informations of the survey and is responsible for the truth and analysis of informations. A.H. and M.I.M.I. conceptualized and designed the survey. A.H. and M.I.M.I. obtain, analyzed and interpreted the information. Manuscript was drafted by A.H and A.H and M.I.M.I. conducted reappraisal of literature.

Recognitions

The writers would wish to widen their grasp to Ministry of Health Pakistan, Government of Pakistan. The writers besides thank the District Health Offices of Islamabad, Peshawar and Lahore for their support during the survey. Particular gratitude to the survey participants and informations aggregators and their caputs of pharmaceutics sections at Hamdard University, Islamabad, Peshawar University, Peshawar and Punjab University, Lahore.

Funding

The writers would wish to widen their grasp to the Ministry of Health R & A ; D fund Pakistan for partial support of this survey.

Pakistan has been enduring from energy crisis since the last few old ages, which has earnestly affected its people. The power sector of Pakistan suffers from a serious deficit of up to 5000MW ( USAID Pakistan: Energy Efficiency and Capacity, 2012 ) . The spread between demand and supply has been invariably widening. Peoples are passing insomniac darks in summer. Load casting has become an issue of all the people. Where the rich people can afford UPS and generators, the hapless 1s can merely afford to bear the effects of power outage. Apart from personal jobs of the people, acute power outages have earnestly paralyzed the commercial and economic activities in the state and are making many hurdlings in development of the state.

If we examine the present energy profile of Pakistan, it is run indoing its energy demands from different beginnings. Pakistan is bring forthing 48 per centum of its electricity from gas, 33 per centum from hydel power, 17 per centum from oil, two per centum from atomic and one per centum from coal. If we examine the figures, it is clear that Pakistan is underutilizing its natural resources to bring forth electricity. We have failed to work those resources that nature has bestowed upon us. We have non decently tapped our natural resources, even though we could hold met our energy crisis by making that and it is clip we look at this facet with unfastened eyes before the state of affairs gets wholly out of manus doing the hereafter coevalss to endure the rough effects.

Energy used by Pakistan and spread between its demand and supply:

Energy usage refers to utilize of primary energy before transmutation to other end-use fuels, which is equal to autochthonal production plus imports and stock alterations, minus exports and fuels supplied to ships and aircraft engaged in international conveyance ( TheWorldBank, 2012 ) . In footings of per capita ingestion Pakistan ranks comparatively low – 164 out of 217 states ( CIAWorldFactbook, 2003-2011 ) . Energy utilizations and national income per capita are straight related, because energy ingestion is critical to the development of an industrial economic system. In malice of being at the lower terminal of the word-wide energy devouring spectrum, Pakistan faces serious troubles in carry throughing its energy demands due to even lesser supply than the demand of energy. The Government estimates that energy demand will go on to turn during the following two decennaries, with Pakistan necessitating an estimated extra 35,000 MW of power coevals capacity by 2020. Based on the analysis, the expected new power coevals build out will be about 7,700 MW of extra capacity by 2020, go forthing a spread of over 27,000 MW. In a nutshell, supply rate is neglecting to maintain in sync with the increasing demand rate owing to industrialisation, growing in agribusiness and services sectors, urbanisation, lifting per capita income and electrification of rural and urban countries.

Possible solutions to the job of Energy crisis:

In order to do up for the shortage and acquire the state out of a serious energy crisis that it is soon facing, both short-run and long-run policy enterprise are needed that enhance the state ‘s capacity to run into its demands. The possible solutions to the energy deficit can be divided into three chief types:

1. Conservation of present energy beginnings

This includes cut downing inordinate ingestion of electricity and hence conveying down the demand for energy. This is short term step that can significantly cut down on the burden during peak demand periods by salvaging electricity. Conservation includes alterations in life style as good installing of energy efficient devices, edifice patterns and electricity distribution and direction programs that optimize the supply when the demand is at its extremum.

2. Importing more energy

Another option to assist increase the energy base of the state is depending on more imported fuel. At present Pakistan meets 75 % of its energy demands by domestic resources including gas, oil and hydroelectricity production. Merely 25 % energy demands are being managed through imports. Presently, programs are underway for importing gas from cardinal Asia. However, this scenario is besides certain to hold a negative impact on Pakistan ‘s balance of payments and hence a more reliable and sustainable beginning of energy is required.

3. Investing in autochthonal renewable and non renewable energy beginnings

The 3rd option for Pakistan is developing its autochthonal capacity to use the untapped potency of its fuel militias. There is important room for development in all resources including oil, gas, coal and hydel – provided that the proficient and commercial restraints associated with the public-service corporation of these resources are overcome.

Coal as a new enterprise for Pakistan:

Despite being a non-renewable energy beginning, surveies indicate that coal is traveling to play a really important function in the planetary energy scenario during the following two centuries. Harmonizing to an IEA study, coal usage is likely to turn from 41 % to 44 % , as a beginning for power coevals, by 2030 due to energy security and monetary value volatility. On the other manus, the portion of coal as a beginning of electricity bring forthing fuel in Pakistan bases at a meager 0.1 % in comparing to the universe norm of 41 % . Given the crisp rise in the oil monetary values in the international market every bit good as the fast depletion of Pakistan ‘s gas militias due to increased demand, it is imperative that Pakistan look towards alternate beginnings of energy including coal.

There are a figure of advantages pointed out in favour of this development. These include:

• Abundance and security of supply.
• Energy denseness comparable to other beginnings of thermic power.
• Relatively easier to develop. The excavation and power production engineerings exist and merely an infrastructural development is required prior to their execution
• Handiness of clean coal engineerings and ways to minimise environmental jeopardies

These are the grounds why Pakistan looks towards inventing a feasible scheme for the development of its coal militias at Thar.

Tharparkar coal mines:

The majority of Pakistan ‘s autochthonal coal resources lie in Sindh. The largest modesty, 175 billion metric tons of lignite coal, is located in the Thar Desert of Sindh. Thar coal is yet to be developed for excavation and power coevals. The development of the Thar resources would supply. The electricity coevals potency of 100,000 MW based on estimated ingestion of 536 million metric tons of coal per twelvemonth, could be a important fuel resource used for proviso of coal base burden capacity in the system supplementing gas based capacity. Further, usage of Thar militias for power coevals would assist in cut downing inordinate trust on imported fuel thereby cut downing the force per unit area of balance of payments in the state. The entire estimated militias in Thar field including measured and conjectural are about 175 billion metric tons. The existent mensural militias are 2.7 billion tones, the oil equivalent of which is 6.59 billion barrels. The oil equivalent of 175 billion metric tons of coal is about 427 billion barrels.

The coal Fieldss cover a entire country of over 9000 sq.km in the Tharparkar desert. The field is covered by sand dunes that extend to an mean deepness of 80 metres. Below that is a bed of sandstone and siltstone which extends from 11m to 127m in thickness. Further underneath are variable sedimentations of clay rock resting on the Bara formation in which coal is embedded. The beds of coal scope in thickness from 0.20m to 22.81m ; the maximal thickness widening up to 36m in certain topographic point. The coal seam itself is present at a deepness of between 114-203m. The chief beginning of H2O in Thar is groundwater. The groundwater is present in three chief aquifers at changing deepness. The mean deepness are 50m, 120m and more than 200m which means that at least one aquifer is located in the coal bearing zone and will back up the mining/extraction processes ( Government of Sind, 2008 ) .

Quality of Coal

Coal quality and its contents have serious effects on the efficiency of the power works in which it is used and besides on the grade of pollution that is created as a effect of electricity coevals. The coal found in Thar is lignite holding a lower warming value as compared to other types which makes it suited for electricity coevals. Its power coevals capacity is 10,289 MW. The brown coal at Thar has a heating value of 6200 – 11,000Btu/lb. Other of import constituents of the coal and their proportion are:

• Carbon ( 19.35-22 % ) ,
• Ash ( 5.18-6.56 % ) ,
• Moisture ( 43.24-49.01 % ) ,
• Volatile affair ( 26.5-33.04 % ) and
• Sulphur ( 0.92-1.34 % ) .

Production of electricity from coal:

Some of the methods of production of electricity from coal are as follows:

Pulverized Fuel ( PF ) engineering:

In this procedure, coal is reduced to ticket pulverization signifier, stored and so transported by air to the burner as coal air mixture for burning. This method involves direct combustion of the coal to bring forth heat that is used to bring forth steam from H2O to turn conventional steam turbines. It is a straightforward technique but direct combustion of coal increases the external costs of energy by let go ofing nursery gases and other toxic oxides and fouling particulate affair into the ambiance in big sums. The efficiency of such a system is merely approximately 33 % .

Fluidized Bed Combustion ( FBC ) engineering:

Fluidized-bed burning ( FBC ) engineering is a type of burning procedure in which the solid coal is suspended on jets of air. In this manner, more efficient commixture of gas and solids occurs, taking to more efficient heat transportation. The low temperature demand for burning reaction is one of the primary advantages because it reduces the formation of toxic azotic oxide. Additionally, FBC engineering causes inexpensive and easy remotion of sulfur dioxide during burning in comparing with the “ stack scrubber ” engineering. Furthermore, add-on of other solid fuels ( such as biomass ) along with the coal can besides be supported by FBC into the reaction mixture.

Coal Gasification ( CG ) technology/IGCC:

IGCCA ( Integrated Gasification Combined-Cycle ) A with Carbon Capture and Storage ( CCS ) engineering allows coal to be used to bring forth power as flawlessly as natural gas.

IGCC engineering has three basic constituents. In the gasification stage, heat, force per unit area, pure O and H2O are used to interrupt char down into its constituent parts and change over it into a clean man-made gas ( syngas ) .The syngas is cleaned before it can be converted into utility natural gas ( SNG ) which finally fuels the power turbines. Staying particulates are removed from the syngas in the particulate scrubber. Carbon monoxide is converted to carbon dioxide ( CO2 ) by adding steam in displacement vas. The gasification procedure makes it possible to capture most of the quicksilver, sulfur and C dioxide ( CO2 ) in the syngas. The captured CO2A will be transported via grapevine for usage in enhanced oil recovery or storage in a saline geologic reservoir.

The IGCC works so converts the syngas into utility natural gas ( SNG or methane ) , through a procedure called methanation. The SNG, which is comparatively high in energy content, powers two gas turbines. Excess heat contained in the fumes from those turbines so heats H2O to power a steam turbine. The higher energy content of the SNG ( as compared with syngas ) improves the efficiency of the power production. This combined rhythm ends up heightening the power works ‘s efficiency up to 60 % .Gasification is the engineering that most power workss are switching towards global and Thar Coal development is besides expected to construct IGCC works for an environmental friendly procedure of coevals of electricity.

The electricity to be produced from the coal gas would be about Rs. 4 per unit

Environmental Analysis:

The beginnings of air pollution from coal based power works fall include C emanations, particulate affair and other nursery gases and toxic oxides. Carbon emanations and other green house gases such as methane and N oxides are of import from the clime alteration perspective whereas toxic oxides and volatile particulate affair pose wellness jeopardies if the human population is exposed to certain degrees. In add-on to these quicksilver and other heavy metals are released which are linked with both neurological and developmental harm in worlds and other animate beings. Fly ash and underside ash are residues created when coal is burned at power works. In the yesteryear, fly ash was released into the air through the smokestack, but now most of it is captured by pollution control devices, like scrubbers.

The chief beginning of groundwater pollution is from the belowground processes that are carried out in the locality of aquifers in order to pull out coal or syngas. This affects the quality of groundwater and besides reduces its measure. It should be kept in head that land H2O is the lone beginning of H2O for the people of Thar.

Dirt and Land pollution is a consequence of the excavation procedure itself as it may go forth the land non useable for agricultural or business by life because of drastic alterations in the surface or deposition of harmful affair in the dirt.

Clean coal engineering and cut downing the harmful impacts of coal excavation:

Clean coal technology is a aggregation of engineerings being developed to cut down the environmental impacts of coal energy coevals. Some clean coal engineerings purify the coal before it burns. One type of coal readying is coal rinsing. It removes unwanted minerals by blending crushed coal with a liquid and letting the dross to divide and settle. Other systems control the coal burn to minimise emanations of S dioxide, N oxides and particulates. A Wet scrubbers, or flue gas desulfurization systems, take S dioxide, a major cause of acid rain, by spraying flue gas with limestone and H2O. Low-NOx ( nitrogen oxide ) burners A cut down the creative activity of N oxides by curtailing and pull stringsing the burning process. Electrostatic precipitators take particulates that aggravate asthma and do respiratory complaints by bear downing atoms with an electrical field and so capturing them on aggregation home bases. Gasification avoids firing coal wholly. With incorporate gasification combined rhythm ( IGCC ) systems, steam and hot pressurized air or O combine with coal in a reaction that forces C molecules apart. The resulting syngas, a mixture of C monoxide and H, is so cleaned and burned in a gas turbine to do electricity.

Carbon gaining control and storage is the most promising clean coal engineering. In order to detect the most efficient and economical agencies of C gaining control, research workers have developed several engineerings. One of them, flue-gas separation is a technique thatA removes CO2 with a dissolver, strips off the CO2 with steam, and condenses the steam into a concentrated watercourse. The CO2A can so be sequestered, which puts CO2A into storage, perchance belowground, in such a manner that it will stay at that place for good. Flue gas separation besides renders commercially useable CO2. Another procedure, A oxy-fuel burning, burns the fuel in pure or enriched O to make a flue gas composed chiefly of CO2 and H2O which saves the energy required for dividing the CO2 from other flue gasses. A 3rd engineering, A pre-combustion gaining control, removes the CO2 before it ‘s burned as a portion of a gasification procedure. The CO2 removed can be stored in geologic or pelagic reservoirs from where it ca n’t come in the ambiance. A Depleted oil or gas Fields and deep saline aquifers safely contain CO2 while deep belowground coal seams absorb it. A procedure called enhanced oil recovery already uses CO2 to keep force per unit area and better extraction in oil reservoirs. All signifiers of CO2 storage require careful readying and monitoring to avoid making environmental problems.

Reuse and recycling can besides cut down coal ‘s environmental impact. Land that was antecedently used for coal excavation can be reclaimed for utilizations like airdromes, landfills, and golf classs. Waste merchandises captured by scrubbers can be used to bring forth merchandises like cement and man-made gypsum for drywall.

The Educational reforms policy has extremely valued the betterment in the instruction sector in Pakistan as stated by Education reforms Policy 2009. On the other manus national authoritiess and employers have argued that it is of import for all sectors of instruction to fix persons who are able to believe good and for themselves ( Pithers, Rebecca sodden 2010 ) . The states with most economic growing and development have rather a good educational substructure and as stated above, They work rather difficult on supplying quality instruction through available resources. Therefore we have a job of importance of incorporating critical thought with the current educational reforms. In this assignment I will foreground some of the instruction sector reforms along with the construct of critical thought. First portion constitute of state portfolio, followed by the work of authorities in the instruction sector and it as the instance survey which is subsequently on followed by an history of the policy of authorities and schemes it presented which shows the complete scenario subsequently on an history on critical thought and it ‘s usage has been elaborated while the decision highlights how it can be used to better the bing authorization of instruction reforms.

1.2 Country portfolio:

Pakistan became an autonomous state in 1947 when British India split into a Muslim province of

Pakistan and a mostly Hindu India. The state is a federation of four states, each one with a parliamentary system, federally administered Tribal Areas and Islamabad Capital Territory.

The four states are Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwah ( KPK ) and Balochistan.

Pakistan is situated in South Asia, surrounding India to the East, Iran to the South West, China to the North East, and Afghanistan to the West and North. To the South is the Arabian Sea. Pakistan is an Islamic Republic. Since 1947 the state has experienced a assortment of democratic and military authoritiess.

Pakistan has approximately 162 million dwellers ( 2005 estimation ) . Most, 97 % of the population is Muslim. The state is composed of several cultural groups of which Punjabi is the largest and rest include Pashtuns, Balochi and Sindhi while several smaller cultural groups.

Punjabi is one of the most widely spoken linguistic communication along with Urdu as the official linguistic communication and English as the linguistic communication of disposal. The public is immature and fast turning with a mean age of 19.58 old ages and a public growing rate of 2.03 % . The state has an estimated literacy rate someplace between 48 % and 54 % depending on the beginnings and the definitions used ( 10 years+ or 15 years+ ) with large gender differences and differences between rural, tribal and urban countries. 32 % of the public lives below the poorness line. The chief employment is within agribusiness sector ( 42 % ) , while 38 % of the human resource work in services while 20 % in industry. The state has been hurt from long internal differences, a low degree of foreign investing in the private sector and wars with India. However, in recent yesteryear, helped by macroeconomic betterments and an addition in industrial production, Pakistan has practiced a positive economic disposition, with an one-year growing in GDP of 6.1 % .

The Fundamental law from 1973 ( article 33 ) needs development of an instruction policy to safeguard the saving, pattern and ascent of Islamic political orientation and rules as enshrined in the instructions of the Quran and the Holy Prophet. The National Education Policy ( 1998-2010 ) clearly states the aim of doing Islamic instruction the codification of life incorporated in all signifiers of instruction.

The instance survey:

1.3 Education Sector Reforms.

The Government ‘s I-PRSP sets endeavoring marks for polishing instruction sector results and the Government has moved to set in topographic point programs to accomplish these marks. The Federal Minister of Education used an Education Sector Reform ( ESR ) plan in 2001 which seeks to offer national leading around the Education For All program every bit good as reference major sectorial issues. The ESR wants to turn to these achievements have been challenged in the past few months, and the Pakistan economic system has been adversely affected by the post-September 11th events. The Government is at work to remain the declared class of action and endure to turn to the organisational reform docket.

Some of the critical letdowns of the yesteryear in the instruction sector by supplying resource mobilisation and use, and presenting institutional reforms at every degree of instruction to progress in administration. Goals are set for increasing literacy, gross primary registration, in-between school and secondary registration and higher instruction, by the twelvemonth 2004.

The attack for traveling towards these aims include a assorted figure of constituents and investings at all degrees of instruction, including an ample sum of literacy programme, enlargement of primary and simple degree instruction, conveying up of a proficient watercourse at secondary school degree, polishing quality of instruction through instructor preparation which is one of chief procedure of educational reforms, higher instruction sector reforms which chiefly aims at instruction higher than class 12, and public private subdivision partnerships. In add-on, the ESR includes new open uping plans in scrutiny betterment, a countrywide instruction appraisal system illustration of which are the HEC and quality confidence programmes, picture text edition libraries, along with early childhood instruction known chiefly as baby’s room and an “ follow a school ” plan. The Islamabad Capital Territory is being utilized to prove a figure of the assorted enterprises consisting the enlisting of instructors on contract bases, implementing preparation exercisings for caput instructors and instruction centres to assist better instructors ‘ educational cognition, promotion of entry makings for instructors and presenting a instructor focused codification of moralss to work out chronic instructor absenteeism. In the context of devolution/decentralization, administration betterments constitutes sturdily in the ESR. Mechanisms are being established to reorganise school control and citizens community boards, provide assorted extra resources for instruction and rationalisation of supervisors to territory degrees. The said Citizen Boards and School Management Committees are given duty for some elements of monitoring and supervising of instructor public presentation which is a critical portion of this country. Self-acting monitoring plans will besides be set up to grade policy and pattern.

The ESR puts a high precedence on consolidation of public private partnerships in the conveyance of instruction services. Encouragements to the private sector to set up schools, peculiarly in rural countries and urban slums would be rather utile in this respect which include proviso of free of cost or concessional land, non commercial services rates, generous grant of charters, and exclusion of certain types of dues and revenue enhancements. The Government has besides taken the chief function in reformation of the Nationwide Education Foundation supplying it with greater independency under the Societies Act. The Sindh Government ‘s “ Adopt a School ” plan has been rather positive in intriguing corporate and other financess to concern text editions, schools uniforms, and other commissariats every bit good as preservation of edifices, and is being replicated in diverse parts of the state. In add-on the Government plans to absorb private sector and NGO schools into the Education Management Information System ( EMIS ) and the National Education Assessment agreement at national and provincial degrees.

In tantamount with the federal authorities ‘s ESR creativeness, provincial authoritiess, wherever duty for instruction remainders, are besides get downing to set in topographic point steps that address some of the most cardinal jobs of the system, such as naming instructors to account through a re-certification procedure, associating wage with public presentation ( attending ) , assignment of new instructors on contract bases and specifically for school with assorted researching ways to run all available underutilized school edifices. Each state has begun to quite earnestly supervise teacher presence and subjective grounds of that has been provided in many countries. To spread out installations, a new start has been prepared on a large backlog of postponeded care and the plan of alot new militias has been rationalized. Education sections are holding duties of stock lists fresh schools and look intoing options for their use, inter alia through “ undertaking out ” battles.

Theory used:

The direction scientific discipline position of the popular organizational acquisition theory, specifically the ‘technical ‘ strand, has been used and applied to this peculiar survey ( Addleson, 1996 ; Easterby-Smith 1997 ) . It foresees that the university administration is infact a system that aligns its purposes to particular action programs to gain awaited results ( Agyris & A ; Schon, 1978 ) . As the university replies to alterations in its ambiance, it is possible that it will besides redefine its purposes or at least alter its action programs in order to obtain satisfactory results as it often adapts to its unstable ambiance. The state of affairs in which the university maps has been considered by worsening and intermittent authorities support, increasing societal authorization for higher instruction, increasing independency and answerability as required by the appraisal and quality bureaus. The reaction of the university can be a new or a counteractive action program could be started by a feedback cringle when the anticipated results have non been attained. In the same manner, the responses of the university administration can be so prevailing that they move the said purposes or programs ( bing norms or values ) that will besides do new action programs to obtain satisfactory consequences. Curative programs or incremental fluctuations are the most common in university organisations ( Boyce, 2003 ) although considerable alterations in the usual norms have besides been reported ( for illustration Clark, 1998 ) . This theoretical statements have been applied as an interpretative model within which the responses of the university to public sector reforms have been evaluated.

Similarly, as it is thought of, critical thought involves aptitudes in add-on to certain temperaments. They are brought to bear in placing a trouble and its associated conventions ; clear uping and concentrating the job itself ; and analyzing, understanding and doing usage of deductions, inductive and deductive logic, every bit good as judging the legitimacy and dependableness of the premises, beginnings of informations or information which is available ( e.g. Kennedy, Fisher and Ennis, 1991 ) .

3. The educational reforms instance:

The chief aim of authorities policy in the past few old ages has been to better the degree and quality of schooling in Pakistan. The authorities vision is to spread out primary instruction and this step can be used to measure whether authorities schools have augmented their coverage, by increasing registrations quicker than the growing in public, particularly at the lower degree because that degree forms the nucleus of the knowing population.

Literacy and primary school registration rates in Pakistan have displayed development during last five old ages but they are still hanging behind other states of the part. Deficit of resources and deficient proviso of comfortss and preparation are the primary troubles in instructing and spread outing instruction. The present authorities ‘s program for the sector includes implementing the operation and usage of bing schools, developing the quality of instruction, spread outing registration, polishing entree to instruction and increasing the primary instruction system.

Under the 18th constitutional amendment during the reign of General Pervez Musharraf ordinance and direction of the instruction sector has been devolved to the states. They are now held responsible for the assorted cardinal countries of the instruction sector i.e. course of study and course of study, centres of excellence, standardisation of instruction up to intercede degree ( Grade 12 ) and it besides includes the Islamic instruction. Planning and policy and standardisation of instruction beyond Grade 12 are covered under Federal Legislative List which is an of import factor in relationship to the reforms in this country. All the states have emphasized their committedness to the National Education Policy 2009.

3.1 National Educational Policy 2009

The National Educational Policy ( NEP ) 2009 is an accomplishment which aims to turn to a figure of assorted aims including:

• quality and measure of instruction in schools and college instruction
• cosmopolitan primary instruction which is a portion of UN docket
• improved Early Children Education ( ECE ) known as baby’s rooms
• improved installations in primary schools both in rural and urban countries
• change overing primary schools to simple schools
• detaching categories XI-XII from college instruction
• following a comprehensive definition of ‘free ‘ instruction which will supply instruction to every citizen
• accomplishing regional and gender para particularly at simple degree in order to continue gender equality
• provide demand based accomplishments and increase in the portion of resources for instruction in both public and private countries

The policy besides defines the motivations of authorities at the federal every bit good as the provincial degree in the country of instruction.

The National instruction scheme is being applied through a figure of different strategies and one of the of import strategy in this respect is the Quality Assurance Programme.

3.2 Quality Assurance Programme

Harmonizing to information from HEC ‘s web site, the mission of the Quality Assurance Programme is to present an integrated quality and confidence direction service for higher acquisition where ends of the strategy are:

• To analyze the spreads in the background of quality of higher instruction in Pakistan
• To run into the tests of planetary adaptibility in higher instruction
• To better the criterions of higher acquisition in cross-cutting countries and assorted degrees
• To develop a executable and maintainable mechanism of quality confidence in the higher instruction sector of the state
• An adviser of Quality Assurance in HEC is in charge for induction of the Quality Assurance Programme.

Under the Quality Assurance Programme, a Quality Assurance Committee was established in 2003. The commission is made of Vice Chancellors from assorted universities with the aim of holding representation from smaller and medium universities and universities for adult females and to better geographical equality. The Team has an extended end to guarantee the appraisal, betterment and publicity of higher instruction. The Committee articulates policies, steering rules and significances for higher instruction establishments, organize programs for the development of the establishments ( in cooperation with the establishments ) and sets up national or regional appraisal councils to transport out enfranchisement of establishments.

One of the first undertakings of the commission was to decide on the Ranking of Universities. The ground for this judgement was to: “ advance positive competition and Foster betterment in criterions of higher instruction programmes ” ; “Harmonizing to the Powers and Functions of the Commission as stated in “ Ordinance No. LIII of 2002, Para 10, Clause vitamin E ” the Higher Education Commission may put up national or regional rating councils or authorise any bing council or similar organic structure to transport out accreditation of Institutions including their sections, installations and subjects by giving them appropriate evaluations. The Commission shall assist construct capacity of bing councils or organic structures in order to heighten the dependability of the rating carried out by them. ”

Accreditation councils in Pakistan have been established for calculating and technology, while councils for accreditation are besides planned for agribusiness, concern and instruction.

National Computing Education Accreditation Council ( NCEAC )

NCEAC is another organic structure that is bettering the quality of instruction pupils receive in topics in applied scientific disciplines, calculating, technology and engineering instruction in the universities and assorted related establishments of higher instruction in Pakistan.

The aims of the said councils are to vouch quality in calculating degree plans in educational establishments by guaranting that programmes run into certain distinguishable criterions or standards. It shall be obligatory for all relevant academic programmes delivered by public and private sector organisations to be accredited by NCEAC. It is besides an aim to guarantee transparence of tantamount survey programmes.

4. Critical thought:

Evaluation is considered as a nucleus ability. Attitudes or temperaments such as a ‘spirit of enquiry ‘ are besides seen by some writers in the field as really of import ( e.g. Ennis, 1993 ; Perkins, Jay and Tishman, 1993 ) . For illustration, Ennis ‘s position of critical thought involves wide temperaments, movable over different spheres such as being ‘open-minded ‘ , ‘drawing indefensible guesss carefully ‘ and ‘considering the credibleness of grounds ‘ . These capablenesss and temperaments occur within a planetary mentality in which thought is abstracted as a type of reasoned statement with an explicitly societal dimension ( Kuhn, 1991 ) .

Kember ( 1997 ) , after analyzing the available published research grounds, it is suggested that learning attacks in third instruction may be influenced by interaction of factors. For illustration, one factor, course of study made, was seen to act upon university and college lectors to be more subjective in nature when learning instead than on the development of critical thought. This may be due to the fact that content is normally specified far more to the full than perchance generalizable the abilities. It seems excessively that instructors are presented small aid in lighting what is encompassed in the impression of ‘good ‘ thought. Thus they are non clear on what it is they are supposed to be assisting pupils to come on. Not amazingly, deficiency of lucidity about the ability of critical thought leads to misperception about how good thought might be measured ; appraisal and rating of critical thought has been greatly neglected worldwide ( e.g. Kennedy et al. , 1991 ) . Continuing confusion about these jobs seems sometimes to take to education attacks to problem-solving which are dubious to develop more widely movable generalizable critical thought aptitudes and mentalities.

Research in the UK farther instruction sector, where the growing of work related thought has been highlighted since the late eightiess, provides illustrations of instruction which is changing with this purpose. Teaching activities probably to develop critical thought were known to be rare in Social Care courses. This was a surprise, provided that the classs in this zone were an induction into a profession which values critical scrutiny ( Anderson et al. , 1997 ) . Bloomer ( 1998 ) reported a similar tendency based upon his research of a scope of assorted programmes taking to the General National Vocational Qualifications ( GNVQ ) . In these classs pupils engaged in much activity, although it seldom included critical scrutiny.

However, there appears to be a deficit of published research which examines the advancement of critical thought during degree-level classs. In a survey of critical thought affecting 256 Scots and Australian university pupils analyzing instruction, an enterprise was made to size critical thought utilizing the Smith-Whetton Critical Reasoning Test ( CRT ) , a moderately valid and dependable standardised psychological trial with assortments available for both states viz. UK and Australia ( Pithers and Soden, 1999 ) . Average CRT sums were equated for class campaigners with grades and those who had no grade, every bit good as for stage ( twelvemonth ) of class. Overall, it was found that there were no notable between-group CRT differences for alumnus V non-graduate students or for phase or stage of the class. In fact, alumnus appliers had CRT tonss non significantly greater than nongraduates nor did last phase ( Years 2 and 3 ) pupils, on a average mark, achieved significantly better than Stage 1 pupils. As a whole, these consequences propose that the kind of critical thought restrained by the CRT, based on Ennis ‘s ( 1993 ) construct which is drawn shortly, was non being good developed in the third instruction class examined in both states. Nor did the critical thought abilities and temperaments measured by the CRT appear to hold been developed significantly by the pupils during their old survey at degree degree. Furthermore, CRT mean tonss for these pupils were non signi. cantly higher than the normative sample agencies provided in the CRT Manual ( Smith and Whetton, 1992 ) for schoolleavers who had taken scrutinies measure uping them for university entry ( e.g. in the UK, A-levels ; in Australia, HSC-level ) .

In a subsequent paper ( in readying ) the writers report cases of critical thought in a sample ( n = 40 ) of essays for a similar grade class whose programme aims included the development of abilities encompassed by the term critical thought ; these abilities were described explicitly in class forms issued to lectors and pupils. Cases of critical thought were rare and there was a high frequence of averments without justification. Lectors, coachs and pupils seemed non to portion an apprehension of what it means to believe critically. These findings, possibly, should non be viewed as surprising, given the published

literature over a comparatively long period about the patterns which inhibit critical thought ( e.g. Raths et al. , 1966 ; Sternberg, 1987 ) . Evidence that pupils enter higher instruction with developing ability to believe critically is another statement for happening effectual steps to advance this ability. Kuhn ( 1991 ) supposed that thought as statement was variably implicated in the beliefs people hold, the opinions they make and the decisions they arrive at ; it was at the bosom of mundane thought. Among Kuhn ‘s ‘skills of statement ‘ are the ability to suggest sentiments alternative to one ‘s ain and to cognize what grounds would back up these, to supply grounds that at the same time supports one ‘s ain sentiments while refuting the options and to weigh the equity of one ‘s ain cogent evidence and that of others. Kuhn provided cogent evidence that none of these aptitudes is widespread in the grownup population in the USA, even among those who have had a college instruction. In a UK engagement, Anderson et Al. ( 1997 ) confirmed that pupils ‘ thought, as conceptualized in Kuhn ‘s theoretical account, could be meaningfully improved ( over that of a control group ) in the normal course of study by infixing steps flinging the chief subjects in the literature reviewed in this paper. The better measure and quality of accounts the pupils incorporated into their study lettering by the 4th month of the invasion were still evident at the terminal of the academic twelvemonth.

Many authors have highlighted that thought and content are closely related. These staffs imply that larning to believe involves larning to utilize content in in turn more sophisticated ways in understanding the universe. Barnet ( 1994, p. 153 ) suggested that an educational purpose should be the growing of wisdom, corporate exchange, and a acknowledgment even a review of interior appraisals ‘ . Bonnett ( 1995 ) claimed that any appraisal of ‘good thought ‘ which fails to afirm the dependability of content is likely to be lacking. Indeed there is sound matter-of-fact grounds that good cognition and good thought are Inseparably tied up ( Bereiter and Scardamalia, 1993 ; Chi, Glaser and Farr, 1988 ) . It appears critical therefore that critical thought is teached in the class of learning subject cognition and implemented through the available agencies at manus. Combination of these thoughts with the descriptions of critical thought already outlined, it appears that one direct and effectual step lectors and instructors could put in in their instruction is to set far more accent on the specific signifiers of concluding within their ain subject country and to supply illustrations of how these signifiers of thought can be applied both within and outside of that subject. Another of import strand in the discourse on ‘good thought ‘ which helps to mix the thoughts antecedently outlined is the impression of self-regulation of thought ( e.g. Schunk and Zimmerman, 1994 ) . The guess is that this metacognitive ability, for illustration, affecting perceptual experience, review, opinion and determination devising, are all factors which allows people to orchestrate and self-regulate their ain acquisition strategies and those capablenesss are included in the term ‘critical thought ‘ . It is critical to add them in the instruction reforms as stated by the groundss shown above where we see a deficiency of any existent important factor that indicates a motion towards foregrounding the accomplishment of term critical thought in the instruction reforms mandate.

5. Decision:

On the bases of the thoughts originating from the current reforms performed by the authorities in bettering the quality of instruction every bit good as the surveies of doing pupils more of a critical mind, the demands of the twenty-four hours are non merely to spread out the current instruction substructure but to do pupils a more critical minds so that better Human resource is available at every degree of the authorities and private sector. ( Pithers, Rebecca 2010 )

It will be really hard for a state that has so many jobs including the first and foremost of security issue since the government alteration in Afghanistan. The primary issues included in this respect are: unrest in the Baluchistan state and tribal countries, a batch of resources traveling waste on protection of atomic assets of the state along with a menace of confrontation with the adjacent India. At the minute the instruction reform looks to be concealing behind these issues of security, poorness and wellness. It is rather likely to stay like that unless a strong committedness from a sure authorities is shown. I suggest that the undermentioned docket should be entered into the instruction policy and implemented through the Quality confidences plans in order to develop critical thought in the pupils and better instruction in Pakistan.

Research grounds suggests that larning to believe good needs to be acknowledged explicitly as an purpose and appropriate alterations made to classs. Lonka and Ahola ( 1995 ) interpreted their consequences as proposing that there are two qualitatively different ways of come oning in psychological science surveies: high-quality active acquisition, which may be decelerate in the beginning, but provides qualitatively better consequences in the long tally, and extremely structured lecture/tutorial instruction, which is related to success in early stages of analyzing. There would look to be benefits in passing the full grade course of study, so that the sum of freshman subject specific information could be reduced to let the pupils clip to prosecute in activities which are likely to develop their rational abilities. The inquiry of how much subject cognition is good for pupils demands to be revisited.

Research suggests excessively at all educational degrees that staff development enterprises may necessitate to concentrate more on instructors ‘ constructs of instruction and learning if they are to set up the instruction methods suggested in a generative manner. In fact some empirical research specifies rather strong relationships between instructors ‘ constructs and instruction attacks ( Kember, 1997 ) .Teachers or lectors who are merely wining the guidelines in plan paperss do non look to learn rational well. Kember suggests that constructs of instruction can be summarized in footings of two wide alliances labeled teacher-centred/contentoriented and student-centred/learning-oriented.The teacher-centred orientation comprises beginnings that instruction is about leaving information or conveyance planned cognition, whereas the student-centred orientation includes beliefs that instruction is about easing apprehensions, advancing theoretical alteration and rational development. It will be about clip that Pakistan ‘s instruction reform policy put a serious idea of presenting it into the current instruction scenario.

Future of Pakistan After a great struggle Muslims of the sub-continent succeeded to get a homeland where they could lead their lives according to their religion. On 14th august, 1947. Pakistan came into being. unto now Pakistan has made much progress in different fields. Although Pakistan has been In troubles from the very first day yet It has made much progress . Now Pakistan is the 6th atomic power in the world. Exploring current images of Pakistan’s futures is the task for this essay. Based on a literature review of

Pakistani magazines, newspapers and Journals as well as conversations with Pakistani scholars and interviews with members of the general public, we develop and evaluate five Images or scenarios of the future. This essay concludes with suggestions for designing alternative futures for Pakistan. Before we articulate these images of the future, let us first examine the “futures approach” to the study of social reality. A futures view focuses primarily on temporality. Where are we going? What are the possibilities ahead? What strategies can we use to realize our goals?

How can he Image of the future help us better understand and change today? who are the losers and winners In any particular articulation of time? The futures perspective Is initially similar to traditional political analysis in that it begins with an exploration of economic, International and social events and the choices made by actors that make these events possible. However, the futures view also attempts to place events and choices within an historical dimension; that is, the larger and deeper structures that make these discrete events intelligible, such as core-periphery. ban-rural, gender, caste, and macro patterns of social change. Also important in the futures view is the post-structural dimension; the larger meaning system or the epistemological ground plan of the real as embedded in language that constitutes events and structures. unfortunately, most efforts to understand the future remain in the predictive mode. It Is often asked. what and when will a particular event occur and how can we profit or increase our power from a specific prediction? Economists and strategic analysts claim to excellent this task.

Our efforts here-sensitive to the richness of reality and the need to decolonize the study of the future from narrow models of reality–is to explore images or scenarios of the future. Our task is not to predict and thereby make this essay political fodder for technocrats but to use the future to create real possibilities for change. We thus do not intend to give a familiar reading of Pakistan’s future, as might be available In a five year plan, rather we enter Into a discussion of alternative futures, of the many choices ahead as contoured by the structure of istory and the modern boundaries of knowledge that frame our identity.

In the images or scenarios that follow it should be remembered that these images are meant as tools for discussion and dialog; they are intended to clarify the futures ahead not to reify social reality. Our goal is Insight not prediction. As an Initial caveat, an important failing of this essay is that the textual sources and conversations were entirely in English–one might get different images with local Pakistani languages.

By Zainabazharl 2 here they could lead their lives according to their religion. On 14th august, 1947, Pakistan came into being. Unto now Pakistan has made much progress in different fields. Although Pakistan has been in troubles from the very first day yet it has made and evaluate five images or scenarios of the future. This essay concludes with the image of the future help us better understand and change today? Who are the losers and winners in any particular articulation of time?

The futures perspective is economic, international and social events and the choices made by actors that make ake these discrete events intelligible, such as core-periphery, urban-rural, gender, Unfortunately, most efforts to understand the future remain in the predictive mode. It is often asked, what and when will a particular event occur and how can we profit claim to excellent this task. Our efforts here–sensitive to the richness of reality and future, as might be available in a five year plan, rather we enter into a discussion of ahead not to reify social reality. Our goal is insight not prediction. As an initial caveat,

In order to achieve full employment and raise its entire population above the poverty line by the year 2006-07, Pakistan needs to create additional employment for 100 million persons and raise the incomes of millions of under-employed persons. This report presents a program to achieve these goals utilizing the country’s competitive advantage in labour-intensive agricultural crops and allied industries. Misfortunes can happen to some very good products. One of the major reasons for such mishappenings, is that industries and organizations fail to realize the importance of a well-planned process of new or existing product development.

They do not acknowledge that “ change is the only constant thing in this world” and as trends change it is important to change their products along with it too. The objectives of the program are to double agricultural production in ten years, achieve complete nutritional self-sufficiency for the country, and generate millions in exports of sugar, fruits, vegetables, silk and cotton textiles. The program will generate a minimum growth rate of more than 4% in the agricultural sector. New changes, are the lifeblood of companies.

When firms do not change their level of production to meet the requirements of changing consumer desires, government regulations completion and a host of other factors: market share and profit usually decline. The life of a new industry often depends on how it conceives and produceses. INTRODUCTION Agriculture Pakistan’s principal natural resources are arable land, water, and extensive natural gas reserves. About 28% of Pakistan’s total land area is under cultivation and is watered by one of the largest irrigation systems in the world.

Agriculture accounts for about 24% of GDP and employs about 44% of the labor force. The most important crops are cotton, wheat, rice, sugarcane, fruits, and vegetables, which together account for more than 75% of the value of total crop output. Despite intensive farming practices, Pakistan remains a net food importer. Pakistan exports rice, cotton, fish, fruits, and vegetables and imports vegetable oil, wheat, cotton, pulses, and consumer foods. The economic importance of agriculture has declined since independence, when its share of GDP was around 53%.

Following the poor harvest of 1993, the government introduced agriculture assistance policies, including increased support prices for many agricultural commodities and expanded availability of agricultural credit. From 1993 to 1997, real growth in the agricultural sector averaged 5. 7% but has since declined to less than 4%. Agricultural reforms, including increased wheat and oilseed production, play a central role in the government’s economic reform package. Role of agriculture in Pakistan.

ARTICLE (September 20 2006): Agriculture is a way of life, a tradition, which for centuries has shaped the economic life, culture and the thought of the people. The importance of agriculture in the development of a country cannot be ignored. Growth of agriculture is very much essential for achieving self-reliance in major food items. Pakistan with a total land area of 79. 61 million hectares is termed as an agricultural country because agricultural sector is the single largest sector of the country which not only provides food to 140 million people but also provides employment to about 48 % of the workforce.

Beside, it also provides raw material to the industry, contributes about 60% to export earnings, and provides the livelihood for 70% rural population. In short the agriculture sector can rightly be called the backbone of our economy, as it contributes around Rs800 billion, almost one-fourth to the total GDP i. e. contributing 25% of the GDP. However, the sector, which possesses the potential to be a lead sector in accelerating the economic growth and reducing poverty in Pakistan, has received less attention from successive governments in the past 57 years than other issues.

According to the Economic Survey of Pakistan, this year the agricultural growth target came down to 2. 6 percent from 4. 1 percent of the last year i. e. 2004-05. The Survey also attributed the slippage in agriculture to the weak performance of both the major and minor crops. However, the government hesitated to accept its poor attention towards this important sector of the economy. Although, the government announced a comprehensive package for the farmers in June this year, it failed to satisfy the majority of the farming community as they are expressing their dissatisfaction over the incentives announced.

Agriculture is the single largest sector of the economy. It contributes 24 percent of the GDP employs 48. 4 percent of country’s workforce and is a major source of foreign exchange earnings. About 68% of the population lives in rural Pakistan and depends upon agriculture for sustenance. The average annual growth rate of agriculture during 1990s was 4. 5%. The highest growth rate of 11. 7 percent was achieved in 1995-96 mainly due to increase in cotton, gram, milk and meat production. The sector touched the lowest negative growth rate of 5. 3 percent in 1992-93 mainly due to decrease in cotton and sugarcane production.

The major crops as wheat, cotton, rice, sugarcane and maize account for 41% of value added and minor crops 10% in overall agriculture. Livestock has emerged as an important sub sector of agriculture. It accounts for 37. 5% of agriculture value added and about 9. 4% of the GDP. Similarly, fisheries play an important role in national income through export earnings. Agricultural Policy The agricultural sector is highly politicized because the majority of landowners have had considerable political influence. This has resulted in agricultural policy being steered towards supporting the production of major

cash crops such as sugarcane, and exempting almost all agricultural income from taxes. However, following recent discussions with the IMF and World Bank on revenue collection in general, the present government is in the process of re-structuring the system to try and increase agricultural taxation. In addition, successive governments have extended considerable support to the sector by providing concessionary financing to farmers for the purchase of agricultural equipment (mainly tractors) and for building irrigation and drainage systems.

Three year Strategy The Ministry of Agriculture is preparing a new three-year strategy. This will focus on the enhanced productivity of export oriented crops and ensure better marketing of exportable crops to get maximum prices of the produce. The new strategy will envisages to improve the performance of the agriculture sector including Higher growth rate of agriculture as compared to population growth Food security and self-reliance in food crops

Enhancing the productivity of wheat, rice, oil seeds, cotton and sugarcane Land and water development for a sustained agricultural growth Farm input supplies supported by appropriate technology to the farmers and at the users’ end, balanced emphasis on all aspects of agricultural production including livestock, fisheries and forestry Improving marketing of agricultural commodities, emphasis on agricultural research to generate innovative technology including biotechnology for rising per acre yield of land.

Improving the productivity of small farmers while encouraging the large farmers for utilization of modern technology. GROWTH IN AGRICULTURE Agriculture is a prime sector of national economy of Pakistan. The growth in agricultural sector and national economy moves hand in hand. The wide fluctuations in agricultural growth have greatly influenced national economy. The sixties was a period of green revolution wherein dwarf cultivars of wheat and rice with high turnover of photosynthesis were introduced.

This brought a quantum jump in productivity of these cereals. This resulted in an average growth rate of 5. 1% during the decade. The growth however retarded in seventies to 2. 4%. The massive nationalization policy of the private enterprises had an overall negative impact on the economy. In addition there was a slow down in the process of varietals development and their release, paltering their potential. However, the seventies was a period of high public sector investments in agriculture sector.

The important institutions commissioned during this decade are Tarbela Dam, Pakistan Agricultural Research Council, Training and Visit Program of Agricultural Extension, Seed Certification and Registration Departments/Seed Corporations, On Farm Water Management and Barani Area Development Programs. In addition Cotton Export Corporation and Rice Export Corporation were established during the decade to provide an export link to indigenous production.

Pakistan day is observed on 23rd march every year. It is an the history of Pakistan. The Muslims of India demanded a separate homeland for themselves through a resolution called Pakistan resolution or Lahore resolution, This year also we celebrated Pakistan day with traditional zeal and fervor and renewed a pledge to make the country strong, progressive and prosperous Islamic welfare state. The day dawned with 31 gun salute in federal capital Islamabad and 21 gun salutes in provincial capitals. Special prayers were offered in all mosques. It was a public holiday.

National flags were hoisted on all public and private buildings. Newspapers published special supplements featuring articles highlighting the importance of the day. They also printed rare photographs of the historical events. Radios and television channels aired special programmes including talk shows. The highlight of the day was the armed forces parade which was held at Jinnah sports stadium. The president and prime minister took the salute of the parade. Similarly in Karachi, the day was celebrated with great honor and dignity. The Governor and Chief Minister of Sindh visited the Mausoleum of Quaid-e-Azam.

They laid floral wreath at Quaid-e-Azam’s mausoleum. The National museum Karachi arranged a special exhibition in connection with the Pakistan Day. This day is indeed one of the most important days in the history of our country. Energy crisis or Load Shedding of Electricity in the town. The people of Karachi know it very well that Karachi has become a city of problems. All these problems go together to make the life of Karachi ties very difficult. Perhaps the most serious of these is what we may call energy crisis there have been an acute shortage of electricity in our city during the last ten years.

As a result the load shedding has become unavoidable. In fact the whole country has fallen a victim into this menace. But the situation is worst at Karachi and with the passage of time the duration of load shedding has greatly increased . Generally we have to pass six to twelve hours without electricity every day. Load shedding is the basic problem which gives rise to many other problems. People cannot sleep at night when the temperature is at its peak. The business of shopkeepers is also hampered particularly the people working on computers and owners of photo state shops are the worst sufferers.

During the darkness the criminals get a free hand and there is an alarming increase in crimes during load shedding. The patients in the hospitals also have to suffer as all the hospitals do not have generators or ups, so it is clear that everybody living in Karachi has to undergo great difficulties. Promises in the reduction in the duration of load shedding are never fulfilled so the problem remains as it was years ago. The Book I like Most. The Holy Quran is my favorite book. It is the name of Allah’s book which has been revealed upon the last Prophet for mankind through the angel Gabriel.

It is most often read and memorized and the most influential book in the world from literary point of view. Holy Quran is considered as the specimen of purest Arabic. It is a master piece of Arabic language and literature. The Quran is guidance for the whole humanity. It is essentially a code of human conduct. It covers all the aspects of human life. It offers guidance to those who seek it. It also defines the causes of decline of the nation. It prompts man to be practical in his daily life. Its importance is recognizes even by the non-Muslims. Its teachings are practically rational.

The knowledge in the Holy Quran is not merely knowledge of religious affairs but also the knowledge of physical and other phenomenon of life. There are thirty chapters’ one hundred and fourteen surahs and six thousand six hundred and sixty six verses (Aayats) in it. By the grace of Al-mighty Allah, I have memorized many surahs with their Urdu translation. Holy Quran is the book which gives me guidance about both the worlds. It tells us what reward we can get if we do good deeds. We can get physical as well as spiritual guidance from it. In short Holy Quran is not only for an individual or a nation but also for the whole universe.

Since the time of independence Pakistan has been facing macroeconomic exertions, such as vicious circle of poverty, less utilization of available natural resources, unfavorable political circumstances that influenced domestic economy and so on. To seize the deficiency, Pakistan has had to depend greatly on financial assistance made by distant countries. Pakistan has been seeking aid since 1947 from global lenders including International Monetary Fund (IMF), Asian Development Bank (ADB) and World Bank.

This financial aid poured mostly in the form of loans or debts with high interest rates. Focal of such assistance is the socio-economic development of the country. Financial assistance once taken as a blessing, appeared as to remove all the dearth of the economy. Resultantly many of the sectors started nourishing at par. Pakistan commenced its way towards developing nation but 2005s earthquake ruined Pakistan leaving its awful economy further worsen.

Though foreign aid showered in the country but, in fact, it directly went to the bank accounts of few effluents and hence with the passage of time, it proved that foreign aid has become a curse instead of becoming blessing, not only perished the confidence of local people but corrupted more government officials. All the authorities here are now seeking more and more aid rather than to rely on their own available resources. Pakistan has already borrowed too much foreign aid in the form of loans and is still borrowing that has reached the historic over $60 billion.

Debt burden is continuously increasing so its interest rates that worth more than the debt itself. Now the economic position is so deteriorated that for the payment of interest, Pakistan tries to get more loans. Pakistan has become now an aid addict and does not make policies to develop their economy with their own domestic resources. Officials do not pay attention for the development of the technology. They just become entirely dependent on others. Major portion of aid particularly commodity aid is misappropriated by the concerned Government officials.

Moreover, when aid is in terms of commodity such as wheat etc, which many times is provided at a very nominal price, discourages local production of that commodity because of higher cost of production within the country. This situation discourages local agricultural production. If donor country has assisted in establishing imported substitution industry then raw material for the industry will have to be imported from loan given country otherwise industry will not continue its production because particular raw material is not available locally.

This causes heavy foreign exchange burden on economy. Pakistan is obtaining foreign aid for bridging gap between domestic savings and investment and also to improve balance of payments position but till now it has not been able to accomplish this task, rather both gaps are continuously increasing. Sometimes aid giving countries interfere in the defense and foreign affairs of Pakistan. That’s why it is said that there are always political strings attached to the bilateral loans. Thus this is to be reveal here that all aid is not for economic rationales but also political.

Most of the politicians misallocate the aid for its appropriate concern so to raise their pay, power and prestige. Thus aid is also promoting greed and selfishness among the leaders of the realm. Pakistan was accessed as an independent nation but Pakistan is now fully dependent on the aid drug to eradicate all the absences. As soon as a new government takes office it is out to woe the US for aid, begs from the Saudis for a few crumbs and looks to countries like China for handouts. This must stop.

To achieve self-respect and start to improve the lives of the impoverished masses the country needs corrective surgery. The starting point should be adopting a culture of austerity and simplicity. The President, Prime Minister, Army Chief and Chief Justice should be given homes and protocol of ordinary citizens. The vestiges of colonial days, the pomp of office must go. Leaders must present themselves as a role model of modesty rather to complex the masses by their luxurious stuff.

One has only to look across the border that how people present themselves in public in simple clothes, sans jewels and accessories, where ministers don’t drive in flashy imported vehicles if a role model is needed. The next step is to generate resources by taxing all. The first step should be agriculture. There is no more favorable time than now. In the past 3 to 4 years produce price including cotton have witnesses a runaway increase and most farmers have had their incomes increase by over 400 percent in three years. Income tax is a failure in Pakistan however consumption tax can be promoted.

All students going abroad for study should be required to get an NOC which would require their parents to explain the source of funds. All property purchase, vehicle purchase and airline ticket purchase should require an NTN number. Put in place consumption taxes. For examples vehicles over 1000 cc should progressively be taxed. Measures such as the above would document the economy and bring more of the black economy into the main stream. With a corrupt bureaucracy, political elite and military this may virtually impossible. So a revolution is needed to unshackle Pakistan.